| Buffalo Chips | Wizards | Phanatics | Uncallables | Insan-Eddy | RoadRunners | Colts | Bimbos | Jabberwocky | Bulls | ||
| C | Molina,B | Shoppach,K | Mauer,J* | Flores,J | Mccann,B* | Molina,Y | Rodriguez,I | Pierzynski,A* | Doumit,R+ | C | |
| Kendall,J | Snyder,C | ||||||||||
| 1B | Youkilis,K | Teixeira,M+ | Kotchman,C* | Pena,C* | Loney,J* | Morneau,J* | Gonzalez,A* | Laroche,Adam* | Overbay,L* | Howard,R* | 1B |
| 2B | Roberts,B+ | Polanco,P | Weeks,R | Castillo,L+ | Hudson,O+ | Uggla,D | Sanchez,F | Utley,C* | Grudzielanek,M | Kendrick,H | 2B |
| Belliard,R | Ellis,M | ||||||||||
| SS | Cabrera,O | Escobar,Y | Eckstein,D | Tulowitzki,T | Punto,N+ | Drew,S* | Rollins,J+ | Bartlett,J | Guzman,C+ | SS | |
| 3B | Beltre,A | Ramirez,A | Zimmerman,R | Encarnacion,E | Gordon,A* | Figgins,C+ | Huff,A* | Kouzmanoff,K | Lowell,M | Reynolds,M | 3B |
| OF | Rowand,A | Pence,H | Young,D | Crisp,C+ | Bay,J | Lewis,F* | Ordonez,M | Guillen,J | Scott,L* | Young,C | OF |
| Winn,R+ | Hunter,T | Kubel,J* | Upton,B | Werth,J | Kemp,M | Mclouth,N* | Schumaker,S* | Dejesus,D* | Braun,R | ||
| Suzuki,I* | Damon,J* | Swisher,N+ | Burrell,P | Sizemore,G* | Ankiel,R* | Byrd,M | Crawford,C* | Lee,Carlos | Jones,A | ||
| Upton,J | Hart,C | Hawpe,B* | Guerrero,V | ||||||||
| Edmonds,J* | Dye,J | Taveras,W | |||||||||
| SP | Meche,G | Baek,C | Liriano,F* | Zambrano,C | Hudson,T | Cook,A | Bedard,E* | Pelfrey,M | Lilly,T* | Vazquez,J | SP |
| SR | Maddux,G | Peavy,J | Harden,R | Buehrle,M* | Haren,D | Perez,O* | Kazmir,S* | Burnett,A | Sabathia,C* | Matsuzaka,D | SR |
| Francis,J* | Redding,T | Blanton,J | Moyer,J* | Wang,C | Laffey,A* | Greinke,Z | Hamels,C* | Gaudin,C | Maine,J | ||
| Pettitte,A* | Baker,S | Myers,B | Maholm,P* | Billingsley,C | Lohse,K | Wainwright,A | Young,C | ||||
| Santana,J* | Garza,M | Garland,J | Sheets,B | Jimenez,U | |||||||
| Hughes,P | Sanchez,A | ||||||||||
| RP | Grabow,J* | Bell,H | Chamberlain,J | Street,H | Jenks,B | Downs,S* | Torres,S | Lidge,B | Rodriguez,F | RP | |
| Franklin,R | Qualls,C | Papelbon,J | Buchholz,T | Delcarmen,M | Saito,T | Francisco,F | |||||
| Wagner, B* | Perez,R* | Marmol,C | |||||||||
| Buffalo Chips | Wizards | Phanatics | Uncallables | Insan-Eddy | RoadRunners | Colts | Bimbos | Jabberwocky | Bulls |