| Player | Year | LG | Pick | Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P | ||||
| Pruitt,A | 2023 | ML | 263 | Venom |
| Pruitt,A | 2024 | ML | 176 | Ramrods |
| Puig,Y | 2014 | NL | 2 | Jabberwocky |
| Pujols,A | 2018 | AL | 113 | Rampage |
| Pujols,A | 2022 | NL | 85 | Road Runners |
| Puk,A* | 2023 | ML | 71 | Ramrods |
| Puk,A* | 2024 | ML | 59 | Rhinos |
| Punto,N+ | 2013 | AL | 85 | Hunters |
| Putnam,Z | 2015 | AL | 41 | Tigers |
| Putnam,Z | 2016 | AL | 173 | Monarchs |