| Year | Champion | Manager | Score | Runner-Up | Manager |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Mudville Nine | Earl Estes | 4-0 | T-Birds | Mike Thurston |
| 2024 | Ramrods | Justin Harmon | 4-0 | Insaneddy | Craig Eddy |
| 2023 | Rampage | Mike Parker | 4-3 | Insaneddy | Craig Eddy |
| 2022 | Insaneddy | Craig Eddy | 4-2 | T-Birds | Mike Thurston |
| 2021 | Keltic Warpigs (NL) | Pat Jennings | 4-1 | Monarchs (AL) | Lewis Hughes |
| 2020 | Rampage (AL) | Mike Parker | 4-2 | Keltic Warpigs (NL) | Pat Jennings |
| 2019 | Dirtbags (AL) | Scott Thurston | 4-2 | Venom (NL) | Jeff Easton |
| 2018 | Ramrods (NL) | Justin Harmon | 4-3 | Bisons (AL) | Scott Thurston |
| 2017 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-1 | Jabberwocky (NL) | John Jimison |
| 2016 | Insaneddy (NL) | Craig Eddy | 4-0 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle |
| 2015 | Venom (NL) | Jeff Easton | 4-2 | Bisons (AL) | Scott Thurston |
| 2014 | Venom (NL) | Jeff Easton | 4-1 | T-Birds (AL) | Mike Thurston |
| 2013 | Taz Devils (AL) | Tim Turner | 4-0 | Bulls (NL) | Pat Manuel |
| 2012 | Venom (AL) | Jeff Easton | 4-3 | Bulls (NL) | Pat Manuel |
| 2011 | Wizards (NL) | Pat Jennings | 4-0 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle |
| 2010 | Venom (NL) | Jeff Easton | 4-1 | Hunters (AL) | Steven Deyerle |
| 2009 | Colts (NL) | Earl Estes | 4-2 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle |
| 2008 | Wizards (NL) | Pat Jennings | 4-1 | T-Birds (AL) | Mike Thurston |
| 2007 | Hunters (AL) | Steven Deyerle | 4-0 | Bimbos (NL) | Keith Gilmore |
| 2006 | Taz Devils (AL) | Tim Turner | 4-1 | Wizards (NL) | Pat Jennings |
| 2005 | T-Birds (AL) | Mike Thurston | 4-3 | Mad Hatters (NL) | Dave Caddell |
| 2004 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-1 | Ducks (NL) | Don Leigers** |
| 2003 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-1 | Road Runners (NL) | Jim Proffitt |
| 2002 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-1 | Road Runners (NL) | Jim Proffitt |
| 2001 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-2 | Buffalo Chips (NL) | Chip Foster |
| 2000 | Bulls (NL) | Pat Manuel | 4-3 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle |
| 1999 | Mad Hatters (NL) | Dave Caddell | 4-3 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle |
| 1998 | Wizards (NL) | Pat Jennings | 4-3 | Mercenaries (AL) | Chip Foster |
| 1997 | Mad Hatters (NL) | Dave Caddell | 4-0 | Black Sox (AL) | Terry Maguire |
| 1996 | Twins (AL) | Paul Blocher | 4-2 | Outlaws (NL) | Ed Orgon |
| 1995 | Black Sox (ALS) | Terry Maguire | 4-2 | Ducks (NLN) | Jim Melillo |
| 1994 | Mad Hatters (NL) | Dave Caddell | 0-0 | Lawgivers (AL) | Terry Maguire |
| 1993 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 0-0 | Road Runners (NL) | Jim Proffitt |
| 1992 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-0 | Seminoles (NL) | Marty Quinn |
| 1991 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-1 | Outlaws (NL) | Pat Jennings** |
| 1990 | Barbarians (NL) | John Walker | 4-1 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle |
| 1989 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-3 | Barbarians (NL) | John Walker |
| 1988 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-2 | Road Runners (NL) | Jim Proffitt |
| 1987 | Whales (AL) | Randy Shavis | 0-0 | Mastros (NL) | Ron Smith** |
| 1986 | Fireants (NL) | Chris Brandt | 0-0 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle |
| 1985 | Tigers (AL) | Richard Deyerle | 4-2 | Mastros (NL) | Ron Smith** |
| 1984 | Mastros (NL) | Ron Smith** | 4-2 | Bees (AL) | Ron Smith |
** Managers playing abandoned or secondary teams. Not reflected in World Series totals.